The recent Delaware ruling in In Ancestry.com Inc. Shareholder Litigation provides a cautionary tale relating to a target company developing aggressive projections during an auction process. The Relevant Facts Following the announcement of a going-private transaction, some shareholders of Ancestry.com filed suit in the Delaware Court of Chancery alleging, among other things, that the board… → Read More
You Can’t Always Get What You Want
Making realistic projections during an auction process
Posted in Private Equity, Private Transactions, Public M&A, Shareholders, StrategyDoing Business in Canada – 2013 Edition
Buying a Canadian Business, eh? A look back.
Posted in Contractual Matters, Private Equity, Private Transactions, Public M&A, Shareholders, StrategyLast Spring we announced a special series of blog posts aimed at addressing some of the most significant distinctions between Canadian and US law that ought to be considered in the early stages of the proposed acquisition of a Canadian target. Following the launch of that series our team blogged about important topics like: Financing… → Read More
OfficeMax and Office Depot Merger of Equals – Who Will Sit Behind the CEO’s Desk?
A Difficult Governance Issue Deferred.
Posted in Public M&A, StrategyOne of the more interesting governance issues in any merger of equals transaction is determining which Chief Executive Officer will take the helm of the combined company. OfficeMax and Office Depot announced the signing of a definitive merger agreement on February 20, 2013 under which the two companies agreed to combine in an all-stock merger… → Read More
Working Capital in Public M&A – Is Varying Cash Consideration the Solution?
Posted in Public M&A, StrategyDealing with a target company’s working capital in the context of a public M&A transaction is often a challenge because the buyer has no recourse against the target’s former shareholders after closing if working capital is not at an agreed-upon level. It’s impracticable to implement a post-closing working capital adjustment mechanism where there’s no one… → Read More
Shareholder Rights Plans – A Priority for the OSC
Posted in Public M&A, ShareholdersOn June 28, 2012, the Ontario Securities Commission published OSC Notice 11-767 – Notice of Statement of Priorities for Financial Year to End March 31, 2013. Tucked in with the OSC’s goal to deliver strong investor protection, the OSC states that it will reconsider the current regulatory requirements governing shareholders’ rights plans to reflect recent… → Read More
Plan of Arrangement – A Flexible “Made-in-Canada” Acquisition Structure
Posted in Public M&A, Shareholders, StrategyOur colleague Matthew Cumming recently discussed some of the most important considerations when choosing between a take-over bid and a plan of arrangement for the acquisition of a Canadian public company. But if you’re like many of our other friends to the South, perhaps you’re wondering, what exactly is a plan of arrangement? The answer… → Read More
Buying a Canadian Business, eh? An Introduction to a Special Series
Posted in Private Transactions, Public M&AWe’re often called upon to provide Canadian legal advice to US-based purchasers contemplating the acquisition of a Canadian business. In many transactions, we act directly for the purchaser; in others we’re asked to provide Canadian support to the acquirer’s US legal counsel. There are many similarities between Canadian and US law but if we had… → Read More
The Implied Covenant of Good Faith and Fair Dealing: Delaware Rocks On
Posted in Contractual MattersEarlier this month, the Delaware Court of Chancery released its opinion in Winshall v. Viacom International, Inc. The Court dismissed a claim for breach of the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing in a merger agreement. The sellers of Harmonix Music Systems, Inc., the creator of the music-oriented video games Rock Band and Guitar… → Read More
7 Tips For Hiring the Right Investment Banker
Posted in Public M&ASo you are on the board of a public company that has decided to explore strategic alternatives, including a potential sale of the company. Or perhaps you are the CEO of a company who is looking at a significant strategic acquisition or divestiture of a business unit or division. You have a great team of lawyers at… → Read More
Financing Condition – A New Item on the Canadian Public M&A Menu
Posted in Public M&APrime Restaurants Inc., owner and operator of a network of casual dining restaurants and pubs (including one of my wife’s faves, East Side Mario’s!), announced this week that it had entered into an agreement to be acquired by Cara Operations Limited by way of a plan of arrangement under the Business Corporations Act (Ontario). One… → Read More
The Clash of the Rights Plan Cases (Redux)
Posted in Public M&A, ShareholdersThe Ontario Securities Commission issued an order this week in connection with a shareholder rights plan adopted by the board of directors of MOSAID Technologies Incorporated in response to a hostile bid made by Wi-LAN Inc. The OSC ordered that effective November 1, 2011 (i.e. 70 days after the commencement of Wi-LAN’s unsolicited offer), MOSAID’s… → Read More
Which M&A Representations Do I Really Need?
Posted in Contractual MattersM&A lawyers often get stuck negotiating pages and pages of representations and warranties in purchase agreements on behalf of their buyer clients. So let’s say I am stranded on a desert island negotiating with “Wilson,” the volleyball, for the purchase of a coconut water business. Wilson will only give me five representations in our purchase… → Read More