Our colleague Matthew Cumming recently discussed some of the most important considerations when choosing between a take-over bid and a plan of arrangement for the acquisition of a Canadian public company. But if you’re like many of our other friends to the South, perhaps you’re wondering, what exactly is a plan of arrangement? The answer… → Read More
Category Archives: Public M&A
Subscribe to Public M&A RSS FeedMAC Primer: An Overview to the Material Adverse Change Clause
Posted in Contractual Matters, Private Transactions, Public M&A, StrategyIn most acquisitions, the distance between signing and closing is measured in weeks, if not months. During this interim period the buyer’s ability to safeguard or control the target’s business is limited. This is an uncomfortable position that can be exacerbated if the transaction is consummated between strategic competitors or in a market with substantial… → Read More
MAC-Ademy: An Introduction to the Material Adverse Change Clause
Posted in Contractual Matters, Private Transactions, Public M&A, StrategyRecently, a curious team of our M&A bloggers presented an internal roundtable discussion aimed at understanding some of the key issues regarding material adverse change (otherwise known as “MAC”) clauses. Part of what came out of that discussion is a presentation that provides an introduction to the MAC clause and some analysis regarding current trends… → Read More
Will the Battle for Fibrek Impact the Canadian M&A Landscape?
Posted in Public M&A, Shareholders, StrategyThe recent saga of Fibrek Inc. has been of great interest to those in the M&A community. Many hoped that it would lead to the Supreme Court of Canada giving its view of defensive tactics and strengthen the hand of boards of directors seeking ways to maximize shareholder value in the face of an unsolicited… → Read More
Financing the Acquisition of a Canadian Business: Cross-Border Credit Transactions
Posted in Contractual Matters, Private Transactions, Public M&AThe acquisition of a Canadian business by US-based purchasers is often financed by way of a cross-border credit transaction involving a Canadian borrower (such as when the US purchaser sets up a Canadian company to make the acquisition, often for tax reasons), possibly also a US borrower (or as is common when a new Canadian… → Read More
Buying a Canadian Business, eh? An Introduction to a Special Series
Posted in Private Transactions, Public M&AWe’re often called upon to provide Canadian legal advice to US-based purchasers contemplating the acquisition of a Canadian business. In many transactions, we act directly for the purchaser; in others we’re asked to provide Canadian support to the acquirer’s US legal counsel. There are many similarities between Canadian and US law but if we had… → Read More
Once Sold, D&O Liability Doesn’t Stop
Posted in Private Transactions, Public M&AWhen a company is sold in an M&A deal, directors and officers remain exposed to claims with respect to activities pre-acquisition. Therefore, D&Os have a lot to worry about when their company is being sold. To protect themselves, D&Os on target boards should try to negotiate the purchase of a run-off D&O insurance policy with the acquiring… → Read More
Cutting Through! Strategies to Address Recent Developments in the Regulatory Review Process
Posted in Private Transactions, Public M&AIn our last post we highlighted some of the important developments in the regulatory rules regarding foreign direct investment and the Competition Bureau’s merger review process. In consideration of these changes, we’ve put together some of the important strategies to keep in mind when conducting a transaction that will fall under these, or any other… → Read More
M&A Activity – Interesting Trends from 2011 and Insights for 2012
Posted in Public M&ASome interesting trends emerged from a study of select US M&A deals in 2011 that may be predictors of what’s to come in 2012. A synopsis of a study conducted by Practical Law Company was provided in a webinar in late January, entitled A Year in Review: Public M&A Trends and Highlights from 2011. According… → Read More
Competition Bureau Increases the “Transaction-Size Threshold” for Pre-Merger Notification
Posted in Private Transactions, Public M&ALast week we discussed the new merger review guidelines released by the Competition Bureau of Canada. On Tuesday, February 7, 2012 the Bureau announced additional changes to one of the key thresholds that trigger pre-merger notification and the review process discussed in our earlier post. In Canada, parties are required to notify the Commissioner of Competition where… → Read More
Competition Bureau Releases New Merger Review Guidelines
Posted in Private Transactions, Public M&AEarlier this month, the Competition Bureau published new Guidelines for its review process under the federal Competition Act. These Guidelines describe the Bureau’s general approach to administering its review process. In general, where a proposed transaction surpasses the “party-size” and “transaction-size” thresholds parties are required to notify the Commissioner prior to completing the proposed transaction. Following… → Read More
New Thresholds for Foreign Direct Investment Review
Posted in Private Transactions, Public M&AIn recent weeks, Industry Canada has announced important developments that affect the regulatory review process for Canadian mergers and acquisitions. Below, we give a brief introduction to the foreign direct investment review process and highlight some of these important changes. Under the Investment Canada Act, Industry Canada is empowered to receive notice and often conduct… → Read More
The Battle for Prime Restaurants Inc. Ends Without Much Sizzle, but Leaves M&A Lawyers With Something to Chew On
Posted in Public M&A, ShareholdersThe recent battle for Prime Restaurants Inc. (PRI) between Cara Operations Limited (Cara) and Fairfax Financial Holdings Limited (Fairfax) settled, which allowed PRI to sign a new acquisition agreement with Fairfax. Before the parties had agreed to settle, PRI asked the court to determine whether the Fairfax proposal was in fact a “superior proposal” to… → Read More
Amending Interim Order and Circular for a Superior Proposal – Plan of Arrangement Leftovers
Posted in Public M&AThe proposed acquisition of Prime Restaurants discussed in this recent post by Robert Hansen continues to whet our blogging appetite. Prime had initially signed a friendly deal to be acquired by Cara Operations via a plan of arrangement and put out a proxy circular dated November 10th with a record date of November 4th and a shareholders meeting… → Read More
Take-over Bid vs Plan of Arrangement: Top 10 Considerations
Posted in Public M&A, StrategyAcquisitions of public companies in Canada almost always take the form of either a take-over bid or court-approved plan of arrangement. Choosing between the two is highly dependent on the facts of each case. It’s not uncommon for bidders to start with one structure and then to flip over to the other as the deal… → Read More
Canadian M&A Activity in the United States Reaching Historic Levels in 2011
Posted in Public M&ADespite continuing economic uncertainty in 2011, the pace of Canadian M&A activity in the United States so far this year has reached historic levels, according to a recent study published by PricewaterhouseCoopers (PwC). Year to date (up to November 14, 2011), Canadian entities were involved in 385 acquisitions of US firms, representing a total transaction… → Read More
What’s the Best Way to a Billion: M&A or IPO?
Posted in Public M&A, StrategyUnless you’ve been living under a rock for some time, you’ll recall the exchange in The Social Network between Sean Parker, Mark Zuckerberg and Eduardo Saverin: “this is no time to take your chips down. A million dollars isn’t cool. You know what’s cool? A billion dollars.” If you’re an entrepreneur or investor with audacious… → Read More
OSC Dialogue 2011: Significant New OSC Policy Projects on M&A Matters Discussed
Posted in Public M&A, ShareholdersAfter a few years on hiatus, the Ontario Securities Commission hosted its “Dialogue” conference once again on November 1, 2011. OSC Dialogue opened with a speech from the Chair of the Ontario Securities Commission, Howard Wetston, and filled the morning with two panel discussions, one on market infrastructure and another on strategic issues in investor… → Read More
Materiality in Securities Legislation: Four Points from the Supreme Court of Canada
Posted in Public M&AOne of the issues in securities law generally is what constitutes “materiality”. In a later post we will discuss “material adverse change” clauses in M&A agreements, but this post is about the fundamental question of what is “material”. A recent case of the Supreme Court of Canada, Sharbern Holding Inc. v. Vancouver Airport Centre Ltd…. → Read More
The Use of Global Depositary Receipts for an Acquisition of a Canadian Public Company – Part 2
Posted in Public M&AIn my previous post, I outlined some of the features of a Global Depositary Receipts (GDRs) program that was utilized by HRT Participações S.A. (HRT), a Brazilian-based and listed exploration and production company, in its acquisition of UNX Energy Corp., a Calgary-based TSXV listed exploration and production company with oil and gas assets located in… → Read More
The Use of Global Depositary Receipts for an Acquisition of a Canadian Public Company – Part 1
Posted in Public M&ADepositary receipts, which are a type of security that is traded on a stock exchange but which represent an interest in an underlying security that is issued by a publicly traded company in another jurisdiction, have been around since the 1920s in the form of American Depositary Receipts (ADRs), and more recently, in the form… → Read More
7 Tips For Hiring the Right Investment Banker
Posted in Public M&ASo you are on the board of a public company that has decided to explore strategic alternatives, including a potential sale of the company. Or perhaps you are the CEO of a company who is looking at a significant strategic acquisition or divestiture of a business unit or division. You have a great team of lawyers at… → Read More
Financing Condition – A New Item on the Canadian Public M&A Menu
Posted in Public M&APrime Restaurants Inc., owner and operator of a network of casual dining restaurants and pubs (including one of my wife’s faves, East Side Mario’s!), announced this week that it had entered into an agreement to be acquired by Cara Operations Limited by way of a plan of arrangement under the Business Corporations Act (Ontario). One… → Read More
The Clash of the Rights Plan Cases (Redux)
Posted in Public M&A, ShareholdersThe Ontario Securities Commission issued an order this week in connection with a shareholder rights plan adopted by the board of directors of MOSAID Technologies Incorporated in response to a hostile bid made by Wi-LAN Inc. The OSC ordered that effective November 1, 2011 (i.e. 70 days after the commencement of Wi-LAN’s unsolicited offer), MOSAID’s… → Read More